Article Safety

Collaboration between the AGS Safety Working Group and the BDA Health & Safety (H&S) Sub-Committee

- by
Tags: Featured

The AGS Safety Working Group provides a platform where industry safety guidance and developments can be shared and promoted to the industry. Paul Breslin, Chair of the BDA Health & Safety Sub-Committee, regularly attends the AGS meetings and delivers a summary of BDA safety developments. Using the AGS platform, there is now an opportunity to share these BDA safety developments to everyone working within the site investigation industry.

Liz Withington, Chair of the AGS Safety Working Group commented that this BDA/AGS collaboration will now become a regular feature in the AGS magazine, reporting on recent developments every quarter.

The BDA Health & Safety (H&S) Sub-Committee met mid-November. The attendees shared updates around hydraulic hose safety, CP rig wind loadings, whole body vibration monitoring, transport compliance, occupational health, and audit administration.

The precis from the November 2025 BDA meeting is presented here:

  • Hydraulic Hoses Position Paper Final Review – The committee confirmed that the updated Hydraulic Hose Position Paper is ready for publication. A short, practical visual inspection will be incorporated into pre-operational checks, supported in future by a training video (to complement, not replace, hands-on instruction).
  • Cable Percussion Drilling Wind Loadings – A contractor query led to discussion on appropriate operating limits for CP rigs in high winds. Manufacturers’ guidance and crane industry recommendations (BS7121 inspired) will be adapted into a BDA advisory document for wider member awareness, and a safety alert will also be issued.
  • Rotary Drilling Non-Compliant Set-up on Social Media – An instance of non-compliant rotary rig presentation on a social media platform was reported. This will be reviewed offline, with follow-up advice to be provided.
  • Whole Body Vibration Testing for Sonic and Vibratory Activities – Initial whole body vibration results were presented and found to be well within exposure limits. Further assessment across full rig fleets will continue, with findings to be shared at future meetings.
  • Towing & O-Licence Requirements – BDA Auditors have reported ambiguity regarding trailers over 3.5 tonnes and the requirement for a restricted O-licence. Further regulatory clarity will be sought to inform a consistent industry position and ensure members understand compliance expectations.
  • Mental Health Communications – A seasonal mental health blog focused on isolation during the Christmas period was prepared and promoted to BDA members, as part of the committee’s wider occupational health focus.
  • BDA Audit Administration – 22 audits have been completed this month, with activity easing towards year-end. To improve the flow of H&S-related information, the BDA membership application form will be updated to capture the designated H&S contact for each member company.
  • Safety Guidance Review – Committee members will review the latest Safety Guidance Status Report ahead of the next sub-committee meeting.

Next meeting is taking place on 5th March 2026.

Image credit: British Drilling Association

Article

Ground Investigation Data Professionals Invited To Support BGS Common Ground Project

- by
Tags: Featured

Professionals responsible for procuring, producing or using geotechnical data are being encouraged to complete a short industry survey to support the British Geological Survey’s (BGS) Common Ground Project.

The research, being carried out by Difference Engine on behalf of BGS, is seeking input from users of ground investigation (GI) data, producers of GI data, those who specify, procure or interpret ground investigations, and developers, asset owners and infrastructure teams managing ground risk.

The survey provides an opportunity for practitioners to help shape the development of a proposed national geotechnical properties data service. The initiative forms part of the Common Ground Project, through which BGS is working to unlock greater value from existing ground investigation data. The project has secured second-phase funding from the Government Office for Technology Transfer.

Ground investigation represents a major area of investment across the UK, with approximately £1.2bn spent annually on GI activities. Despite this, unforeseen ground conditions continue to contribute to project delays and an estimated programme overspend of around 10 per cent — equivalent to approximately £120m each year.

The Common Ground Project aims to improve how existing data is accessed, shared and applied, with potential benefits including earlier risk reduction, improved planning decisions, reduced duplication, increased efficiency and support for carbon reduction.

Input is particularly valuable from professionals who have experienced challenges accessing or using ground investigation data, have had to repeat investigations due to unavailable historic information, have encountered unforeseen ground conditions late in project programmes, or have struggled to benchmark geotechnical parameters with confidence.

Stakeholders who wish to contribute are invited to complete the survey as soon as possible:
👉 https://cobaltskysurveys.com/mrIWeb/mrIWeb.dll?I.Project=J2025sketchbook005_BritishGeologyS1&ID=client420

Alternatively, those interested in taking part in the wider research can contact the Common Ground team at commonground@bgs.ac.uk.

 

Article

Q&A with Sandra Carvalho

- by
Tags: Featured

Name: Sandra Carvalho

Job title: Instrumentation and Monitoring (I&M) Contracts Manager for BAM

What company do you work for, and what do they specialise in?

Our Ground Engineering capability at BAM has evolved from the foundation established under the BAM Ritchies name. Historically delivering specialist ground engineering solutions — including soil nailing, piling, ground anchors, and ground investigation — we have continued to expand and innovate. Over the last three to four years we have been also developing our Instrumentation and Monitoring department, which I was hired to manage.

How long have you worked in the industry for and what inspired you to join?

I’ve worked in the Instrumentation & Monitoring industry for 23 years. My interest in the ground engineering world started in high school, where a geology module sparked my curiosity about how the earth behaves. That led me to pursue a degree in Geological Engineering at university. My entry into the I&M field was somewhat unexpected — the Foundations and Geotechnics company where I began as a trainee needed support in their monitoring department. After stepping into the role I quickly found that I loved the mix of data, engineering, and problem‑solving, and my career has grown from there.

What does a typical day look like?

As an Instrumentation & Monitoring Contracts Manager, my typical day balances technical oversight, client engagement, and commercial management. I start by coordinating with engineers and subcontractors to ensure safe and efficient site activity. I spend part of the day meeting with clients to discuss progress, resolve issues, and provide clarity on monitoring results. I also manage contract deliverables, track costs, and address any scope changes. Throughout the day, I’m problem‑solving, making data‑driven decisions, and ensuring our monitoring systems provide reliable information for asset safety and project delivery.

What is your favourite thing about your role?

My favourite part of the role is being at the intersection of technical insight, problem‑solving, and client engagement. I enjoy turning complex monitoring data into clear, practical decisions that keep assets safe and projects moving. I like the pace and variety — no two days are the same — and I take pride in coordinating teams, resolving issues quickly, and building strong relationships with clients. The role allows me to have a real impact by ensuring monitoring is reliable, risks are managed, and the work we deliver genuinely supports safe and efficient infrastructure delivery.

What lessons have you learnt throughout your career?

Throughout my career, I’ve learnt several key lessons. First, the importance of accuracy and attention to detail — in I&M even small data errors can lead to major consequences, so robust processes and quality control are essential. I’ve also learnt that effective communication is just as important as technical expertise; translating complex data into clear, practical messages builds trust with clients and improves decision‑making. Another lesson is adaptability — technology, client expectations, and site conditions change constantly, so staying flexible is crucial. Finally, I’ve learnt that strong relationships, whether with engineers, suppliers, or clients, are the foundation of successful project delivery.

Who or what inspires you?

I’m inspired by people who stay calm under pressure and lead with integrity. Colleagues who combine technical expertise with clear communication motivate me. I’m also driven by the impact our work has on infrastructure safety and by the constant innovation in I&M, which pushes me to keep learning and improving.

What can the industry do to entice more young people to join?

The industry needs to increase visibility and show young people how exciting and meaningful this work is. More outreach in schools, clearer career pathways, and hands‑on opportunities like apprenticeships can make a huge difference. Showcasing new technology, innovation, and the real impact of monitoring on safety will hopefully attract more young talent.

What advice would you give someone who is considering entering the industry?

My advice is to stay curious and learn as much as you can early on. The industry is evolving quickly, so embrace new technology and hands‑on experience — it’s the best way to build confidence. Don’t be afraid to ask questions; people are always willing to help. Finally, be patient — expertise in monitoring develops over time, but it’s a rewarding field with huge opportunities for growth.

Article Sustainability

HVO vs Synthetic Fuels: A Practical Comparison for the GI Industry

- by
Tags: Featured

The ground investigation (GI) sector is under mounting pressure to decarbonise. Clients, regulators, and the public expect visible progress, and the industry is responding with a mix of innovation and pragmatism. Two alternative fuels, palm oil free Hydrotreated Vegetable Oil (HVO) and synthetic fuels (such as Gas-to-Liquid (GTL)) are now widely discussed as practical options for reducing emissions from plant and transport. But how do they really compare in terms of sustainability, performance, risk, and procurement for GI projects?

This article aims to provide a clear, evidence-based comparison, drawing on the latest industry guidance, certification schemes and feedback from across the sector. The goal is to help GI professionals make informed decisions that balance environmental responsibility, operational reliability and commercial reality.

What is Palm Oil Free HVO?

Palm oil free HVO is a second-generation biofuel made from 100% renewable and waste-derived feedstocks, such as used cooking oils and animal fats. All UK HVO is imported from Europe, Asia and the USA. Unlike first-generation biodiesels (Fatty Acid Methyl Ester (FAME)), HVO is chemically stable, resistant to water ingress, and free from sulphur and aromatics.

Once processed into HVO, it’s impossible to distinguish sustainable palm oil waste from virgin palm oil, the latter which may carry links to unethical practices including potential modern slavery. This lack of transparency is a key reason why some clients have chosen to ban HVO on their sites.  Therefore, to ensure sustainable HVO is being used, it requires certification before use of each batch.

To ensure traceability and sustainability, HVO can be certified under schemes such as the International Sustainability and Carbon Certification (ISCC) and the UK’s Renewable Fuels Assurance Scheme (RFAS), and are now widely available from suppliers such as Certas and Speedy.

HVO has many benefits, including:

  • Drop-in fuel: HVO is a direct replacement for diesel, requiring no engine modifications and it meets the EN15940 standard for paraffinic fuels.
  • Green House Gas (GHG) savings: When made from genuine waste feedstocks, HVO can deliver up to 90% lifecycle greenhouse gas (GHG) reduction compared to fossil diesel.
  • Air quality: HVO produces lower nitric oxide, nitrogen dioxide, particulates, and CO2 emissions than standard diesel, but real-world benefits depend on engine type, after-treatment, and maintenance.
  • Storage: HVO has a long shelf life (up to 10 years), is less prone to microbial growth (“diesel bug”) than FAME biodiesel, and is more stable in storage than standard diesel.
  • Original Equipment Manufacture (OEM) approvals: HVO is approved by a wide range of plant and vehicle manufacturers including JCB, Caterpillar, Volvo and Komatsu.

Surprisingly  prices in mid-2025 for HVO are slightly lower (~£1.37 – £1.40 per litre) than fossil diesel (~£1.44 – £1.47 per litre).  Beyond cost, the environmental benefits, improved reputation, and long-term savings make HVO a strong choice for use on your sites.

HVO is already in use across several RSK businesses, including Structural Soils and RSK Habitat Management, with successful trials at sites like Avonmouth and Lichfield. However, as discussed above, not all HVO is created equal. Sustainability depends heavily on feedstock sourcing, and some suppliers still rely on virgin crops or palm oil derivatives. Furthermore, demand for used cooking oil (UCO) is rising and there is a risk of supply interruptions.  Therefore, controls and supplier audits are essential to ensure genuine environmental benefit.

What are Synthetic Fuels?

Synthetic fuels in the context of the GI industry usually refers to Gas-to-Liquid (GTL) diesel, produced from natural gas via chemical conversion (Fischer-Tropsch process). GTL is also paraffinic, FAME-free, and meets EN15940, but is fossil-derived.

There are some benefits of Synthetics, including:

  • Drop-in fuel: GTL is a direct replacement for diesel, requiring no modifications.
  • Air quality: GTL offers reductions in particulates and NOx, but does not deliver significant lifecycle GHG savings compared to fossil diesel.
  • Sustainability: GTL is not renewable; its main benefit is improved local air quality, not carbon reduction.

However, there are challenges, including:

  • Energy-intensive production
  • Limited commercial availability
  • Slightly cheaper than HVO; however, 10% more expensive than diesel.

Therefore, synthetic fuels are promising but not yet practical for widespread use in GI applications. Their deployment is constrained by cost and scale, and production volumes remain low.

Certas Energy and Speedy have confirmed that their HVO is derived from waste-based feedstocks and meets stringent sustainability criteria. They have also highlighted the importance of transparency in sourcing and carbon accounting.

Looking Ahead

For the GI industry, HVO represents a viable interim solution and is now widely available in the UK.  However, supply is still limited by the availability of genuine waste feedstocks and the UK is reliant on imports from Europe, Asia and the USA.  Reflecting the cost of both certification and the limited supply of waste feedstocks, HVO carries a cost premium over standard diesel and GTL. As demand for UCO is rising, there is a risk of supply interruptions; therefore, long-term agreements with reputable, RFAS approved suppliers are recommended for critical operations.

Increasingly, Tier 1 contractor clients are mandating HVO or equivalent for site operations and some require evidence of RFAS certification and batch-specific Renewal Fuel Declaration (RFD’s).

Synthetic fuels may play a role in the future, but for now, their deployment is constrained by availability and scale.

As we move towards net zero, it is essential to balance ambition with pragmatism and HVO, when responsibly sourced, offers a meaningful step forward. Therefore, continued investment in hydrogen and synthetic fuel technologies will be key to achieving long-term sustainability.

Structural Soils, part of the RSK Group, with our clients approval, have been using HVO fuel on the majority of our larger sites in our plant.

Further information on Responsible Sourcing of HVO can be found on Supply Chain Sustainability School follow the link below. https://learn.supplychainschool.co.uk/local/resourcelib/catalogitem.php?id=8460

Article provided by Eric Downey, Associate Director, Structural Soils Ltd www.soils.co.uk

Article

Eurocode 7: Done and dusted? Yes, but…

- by
Tags: Featured

At a CEN/TC250/SC7 meeting in Brussels in mid-December 2025, the implementation of the second generation of Eurocode 7 was discussed. During the opening of the meeting the chair of SC7 congratulated all the countries in Europe that have made the second generation of Eurocode 7 a reality. However, the main reason for the meeting was to discuss the differences (and similarities), between countries in Europe with respect to the implementation of the new code, and to look at what national choices would be made to facilitate the implementation of Eurocode 7 on a country-by-country basis.

In practice this implementation will be achieved using National Annexes that each country will write and use in conjunction with Eurocode 7.

What is a National Annex or NA?

European Normative Eurocodes allow National Standards Bodies (NSBs), to produce a standalone National Annex (or annexes), (NA) which contain national choices and application of informative annexes.

National Annexes are the original national standardization documents that contain information on parameters which are left open in Eurocodes for national choice and known as Nationally Determined Parameters (NDP).

In the UK the British Standards Institution (BSI), is responsible for the publication of standards as well as the UK national annexes. In reality of course the preparation and writing of these documents is done by technical committees under the BSI umbrella.

B/526 is the committee responsible for geotechnics in the UK. This committee which is made up of technical experts drawn from UK contractors, consultants and clients, is split into three sub-committees, with each sub-committee responsible for one of three parts of Eurocode 7. The coverage or remit of these sub-committees is shown in Figure 2.

Figure 2: Technical coverage of the BSI B/526 sub-committees

Within the committee structure shown in Figure 2, there exists the technical expertise to help draft the national annexes, that the UK geotechnical industry will use when implementing the second generation of Eurocode 7. These committees and sub-committees circulate their work to industry for public comment and then eventually following industry agreement, the national annexes are finalised and published.

National (Country) differences

The geotechnical design experiences of countries in Europe differ considerably. The mere fact that so many countries were able to agree on a Europe wide geotechnical document in the form of Eurocode 7, is in itself remarkable.

However, each country has different technical, legal and legislative practices when it comes to construction projects. For those countries where the use of documents such as Eurocode 7 are enshrined in law, there needs to be some ‘wriggle room’ to make sure that a single unified document such as EC7, can be made to work in practice. This is where the national annexes fit in.

Without changing the principles or main design equations etc that are laid down in Eurocode 7, individual countries can write a national annex, that allows them to make use of historic practices that are unique to that country.

Over the last few months, the management committee for Eurocode 7, has been drafting questions on key areas of the code. These questions relate to key aspects of each of the three parts, for which it was anticipated that individual countries would want to establish NA’s to accommodate their national practices. Much of the seminar in Brussels was taken up with a review of the national responses to these questions.

The sections within the three parts of Eurocode 7 that required analysis and discussion during the seminar are shown in Figure 3 below.

Figure 3: Summary of the sections within Parts 1, 2 and 3 of EC7 requiring discussion

In Figure 3, everything marked with an asterix, needed to be discussed. The discussions ranged from relatively simple topics such as the minimum amount of ground investigation required for a particular design case, to detailed design cases on for example the sliding of spread foundations. Presentations were made by different countries relating to how these different aspects of the code would be dealt with by their country’s geotechnical community.

Whilst it was clear from the presentations that there were distinct differences in approach to the use of the new three-part Eurocode, it was also encouraging to learn that countries were confident that the code could be made to work via the use of national annexes or in some cases via the use of handbooks or guides. The latter two were particularly favoured by those countries in which there was no well-established procedure for making use of a single unique point of reference such as Eurocode 7.

Via a live poll carried out during the discussions, questions were raised about how countries would go about dealing with the prescriptive rules that arise within Eurocode 7. The results of these surveys are shown in Figures 4 and 5.

Figure 4: Question on the allowance of Prescriptive Rules on a National Basis

Figure 5: Response from countries as to where Prescriptive Rules will be presented

As can be seen from Figure 4, 98% of those countries that responded said that prescriptive rules would be allowed, albeit in some cases with restrictions. As to where the prescriptive rules would be presented on a national basis, Figure 5 shows an even spilt between those countries like the UK that will use national annexes, and those countries that will make use of more detailed guidelines or handbooks.

Conclusions

Overall, the seminar in Brussels was very positive and national delegates were generally optimistic about making the second generation of Eurocode 7 work for their geotechnical communities.

As noted earlier in this article, it is no mean feat that the European geotechnical community has been able to produce such a comprehensive, but at the same time useable code for use across Europe. The author has been working on the new code for some fifteen years now and will via his role within the geotechnical committee of BSI (B/526), help to ensure ease of use for the new code.

Within the UK, it is anticipated that there will be increased publicity and presentations on the new code to help the UK geotechnical community become fully aware of both the code’s content, but also more importantly how the implementation of the code can be successfully managed and incorporated into the geotechnical design of new structures.

Unlike the first generation of Eurocodes in which the UK was very ‘late to the party’, the second generation has had significant UK technical input form the outset. This has helped to ensure that what we do in the UK in terms of geotechnical design is reflected in the new code.

Article provided by M.J.Baldwin

Article Contaminated Land

BS10175:2026 Investigation of potentially contaminated sites – Code of practice

- by
Tags: Featured

BS10175 provides key guidance for the investigation of potentially contaminated land and land with naturally elevated concentrations of potentially harmful substances.

It has been fully revised. However, it is inevitable when a document that has undergone several revisions since it first appeared in 2001 (it has deeper roots going back to guidance produced by the GLC Scientific Branch in 1976[1]) that the changes are incremental consisting mainly in changes of emphasis, technical clarifications, and regulatory alignment, rather than major technical innovations.

In summary, the changes are:

  • Amendments 1 and 2 have been consolidated into the core text and external references updated to reflect the latest UK and international guidance.
  • New technical content, including an informative annex on leaching tests and expanded sections on bioavailability, bio-accessibility and the use of on-site measurement methods.
  • Attention to broader issues that have grown in relevance over the past decade, including climate change, sustainability of site investigation activities, and worker wellbeing.

BS 10175:2026 is intended for use by those with an understanding of the risk-based approach to the assessment of sites (as described in the Environment Agency’s guidance on land contamination risk management (LCRM) (available at https://www.gov.uk/government/ publications/land-contamination-risk-management. lcrm)).

Investigation and assessment of potentially contaminated sites will almost always require involvement of people with differing professional and technical backgrounds. The subject is so multi-faceted that an individual is unlikely to have all the skills and expertise required to deal with complex sites. However, each specialist involved in a project usually needs to have an awareness of knowledge outside of their own discipline, especially as they become more involved in the design of investigations and the assessment of the results. This creates the need for the extensive informative text and annexes to aid the understanding of technical aspects that might be outside of a user’s direct training and experience.

Given the diverse usage and application of the code of practice, it is essential that consistent terminology is used in BS 10175:2026 and, as far as practical, related standards, to avoid serious misunderstandings between those with differing backgrounds. This includes the meaning attached to “contamination” and exactly what do we mean by “soil” (see Box 1). Terms need to be defined in reports to avoid unwitting ambiguity.

BS 10175 is a Code of Practice. It provides recommendations and guidance. It is not to be quoted as if it were a specification. Users may substitute any of the recommendations with practices of equivalent or better outcome. However, any user claiming compliance with this British Standard is expected to be able to justify any course of action that deviates from its recommendations.

The requirement for users to apply judgement in this way is important because BS 10175 relies on many other standards (e.g. members of the BS ISO 18400 series) for additional guidance and information, which will often themselves need some updating. A case where this has been important in the revision is the guidance provided on purging of groundwater monitoring installations which is now “stand alone” in BS10175 rather than relying on other published standards and guidance documents.

The development of a Conceptual Site Model (CSM) at an early stage is vital step on the way to a successful investigation. BS 10175:2026 employs the definition in BS EN ISO 21365 Soil quality – Conceptual site models for potentially contaminated sites. BS EN ISO 21365 emphasises that CSMs are “of the mind”, their dynamic nature including the need to continuously revise them as new information becomes available, and the need to produce different CSMs for different purposes as projects progress. It also emphasises the need to have regard to models developed for other purposes including the geotechnical ground model and the ecological and archaeological aspects of the site.

Further discursive accounts of BS 10175:2026 can be found at:

https://bit.ly/4qWRQJ8  and BS 10175 – Executive Briefing

Finally, thanks to all those who contributed to the revision BS10175. It would not have come to fruition without the efforts of BSI staff, the members of the drafting panel, and all those who found the time to comment on the Draft for Public Comment (DPC). The public comment stage is vital for the technically sound development of all British, European and International Standards.

[1] Greater London Council (GLC) – Materials Information Group, Development and Materials Bulletin (2nd series) No. 98, Aug/Sept 1976 –  “Some guidelines for the re‑use of industrially contaminated land.”

Or see:

Chapman W B, Baker P and Burns D, Some guidelines on the re-sue of industrially contaminated land, Journ. Assoc. Public Analysts, 1977, Vol 15, pp 1-25. [Paper to Symposium on Toxic Waste and Environmental Pollution, London, March1976].

Box 1: A few key definitions in BS10175:2026
Conceptual site modelB is defined as:

“synthesis of all information about a potentially contaminated site relevant to the task in hand with interpretation as necessary and recognition of uncertainties.”

ContaminationA is defined as:

“presence of a substance or agent, as a result of human activity, in, on or under land, which has the potential to cause harm or to cause pollution.”

Note that no judgement is made as to whether the presence of the contamination matters. This will depend upon the context, including what is present, how much is present and what are the actual or potential receptors (e.g. humans,  groundwater, etc.).

SoilA is defined as:

“topsoil and subsoils; deposits such as clays, silt, sand, gravel, cobbles, boulders and organic matter and deposits such as peat; material of human origin such as wastes; ground gas and moisture; and living organisms.”

Sources: A – BS10175:2011, B – BS EN ISO 21365:2020

Article provided by Mike Smith, Chair Technical Committee EH/4 Soil quality

Article Loss Prevention

Embracing AI in geo-engineering – the benefits and pitfalls

- by
Tags: Featured

It is safe to say that the age of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has arrived, whether wanted or not. It is probably unreasonable to avoid using AI as we look to the future. To many younger and upcoming professionals, AI is a ‘go to’ tool in the way a slide rule or log tables were to historical engineering pioneers. There are many opportunities to be had in the use of AI, but this is tempered by risks which need to be recognised and managed appropriately.

Within the geo-engineering industry, it is typically text based Large Language Models (LLMs) such as ChatGPT, or CoPilot that are most familiar. These are generative models and can be fine-tuned for specific tasks. They also acquire predictive power based on the data they are trained on. This data may or may not by accurate! There are other forms of AI being used in the industry, but with same pro’ s and con’s.

It is recognised that AI has the potential to be used to enable efficiencies in day-to-day processes. In simple terms, the ideal being that routine processes can be streamlined, freeing up time for innovative thinking and developing solutions. Such efficiencies may be achieved in, for example:

  • Reporting
  • Specifications
  • Meeting minutes
  • Correspondence
  • Presentations
  • Diagrams/ Drawings
  • Document management
  • Information searches
  • Data management/ analysis

As a result there has been an increase in reliance on AI in creating/ undertaking the above.  However, such benefits come with a ‘warning’.  All of the above still require ‘due care and diligence’ in the production process, without which Professional Indemnity insurance will likely be invalid….but what does reasonable ‘due care and diligence’ look like?  It also raises the question …At what point does the use of AI become a requirement of meeting the ‘due care and diligence’ obligation?

When a process relies on AI, it becomes even more essential that the appropriate due care and diligence is applied, as the liability for AI derived deliverables likely does not sit with the software or its originator, but more likely with the human individual/ organisation that adopts the AI output (although subject to testing through the Courts)…There is a significant risk in accepting AI generated output at face value, so what might appear to be a quick and simple solution could be a recipe for disaster if not properly managed and controlled.

If AI is to be adopted safely, as with all other processes, a quality system of checks and balances has to be in place in terms of accuracy and validity of the questions asked and the information retrieved. The more AI is relied upon, the more robust such quality checks have to be. As with all computer models..garbage in = garbage out.

Consideration is required of accuracy of the data used by the AI model, how that model has been trained and whether and how relevant are the data sources accessed, along with qualitative testing, repeat questioning and validation of results. The question must be asked… ‘Is this the right tool for the job?’

A possible solution may be amendment of standard forms of appointment to include specific clauses relating to the use of AI, by defining which AI tools are permitted for use and how their outputs must be verified. Furthermore, a clear allocation of liability is recommended for failures attributable to the AI tool, apportioning risk between the relevant project team parties and the Client.

There are also risks associated with confidentiality of data, both as a source and an output. What data is permitted to be input into models? Are there licensing and Intellectual Property issues associated with sharing of data? These must be considered.

A further consideration is that whilst there may be efficiencies in time/ resources, there is also an environmental impact from the use of AI models. The huge computing capacity required to power the AI models has a significant carbon footprint. For projects where carbon management and/or measurement is required, and may be a contractual requirement, the scope and scale of use of AI will need to be considered and included in carbon calculations.

(This article is based on the presentation given by Ben Gilson of Arup at the AGS Annual Conference 1/5/25 and “A Brave New Blueprint: The Legal and Contractual Quagmire” by Craig Roberts, Griffiths and Armour, 7/11/25).

Article provided by Jo Strange (AGS Honorary member)

Article Laboratories

6PPD-Quinone (6PPD-q) From Tyres to Streams: Ecotoxicology and Regulation in the United States, United Kingdom, and European Union

- by
Tags: Featured

6PPD-quinone (6PPD-Q) is an oxidation transformation product of the tyre antiozonant 6PPD and has been identified as the principal causal toxicant in urban runoff mortality syndrome in coho salmon (Tian et al., 2021; Tian et al., 2022). 6PPD-Q can leach from tyre wear particles (TWPs) and be transported in stormwater; field studies have measured storm-associated concentrations from low ng/L into the µg/L range, with episodic peaks capable of exceeding acute-effect thresholds for coho salmon (Johannessen et al., 2022; Hu et al., 2023; Lane et al., 2024). Coho salmon are exceptionally sensitive, with reported acute LC50 values of 41–95 ng/L, whereas other fish and tested freshwater invertebrates show markedly different sensitivities (Tian et al., 2022; Brinkmann et al., 2022; Lo et al., 2023; Prosser et al., 2023). Reliable quantification is achieved using LC-MS-based methods supported by isotope-labelled standards and matrix-appropriate QA/QC; US EPA Draft Method 1634 provides a current LC-MS/MS framework for aqueous matrices (Tian et al., 2022; US EPA, 2024c).

Regulatory responses are advancing internationally. In the United States, the US EPA has published an acute freshwater screening value for 6PPD-Q and issued an Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking under the Toxic Substances Control Act (TSCA), while California requires manufacturers of motor vehicle tyres containing 6PPD to undertake alternatives analysis (US EPA, 2024a; US EPA, 2024b; DTSC, 2023). In the United Kingdom, the Environment Agency has identified 6PPD-Q for further detailed assessment within its tyre-additive hazard and risk prioritisation work (Environment Agency, 2025). In the European Union, the Netherlands and Austria have notified an intention to prepare a REACH restriction proposal covering 6PPD and related compounds in rubber tyres, with the Annex XV dossier expected in March 2027 (ECHA, 2026).

Mitigation should combine source-side evaluation of safer alternatives with controls that reduce roadway runoff reaching sensitive waters. Full-scale field evidence shows that bioretention can reduce 6PPD-Q mass loading to receiving waters by more than approximately 90% under typical storm conditions (Rodgers et al., 2023). Human biomonitoring studies have detected 6PPD and 6PPD-Q in urine and in paired plasma and urine, demonstrating exposure but not establishing adverse human health risk; chronic human toxicological and epidemiological data remain limited (Du et al., 2022; Liu et al., 2024).

Key messages for regulators and industry

  • 6PPD-quinone is a stormwater-transported contaminant that is acutely toxic to coho salmon at tens of ng/L, although sensitivity varies markedly between species.
  • Monitoring should target rainfall and first-flush events and use well-controlled LC-MS/MS methods, appropriate isotope-labelled standards, and sample-handling procedures that minimise sorptive losses.
  • Risk management should combine evaluation of safer tyre formulations with effective stormwater treatment while maintaining tyre performance and road safety.
  1. Introduction

6PPD is a widely used antiozonant and antioxidant in tyre rubber that protects against ozone- and oxidation-induced degradation. During tyre use and environmental exposure, 6PPD can be oxidised to 6PPD-quinone (6PPD-Q), while tyre and road wear particles provide a continuing source of tyre-derived chemicals to roadway dust and runoff (Tian et al., 2021; Seiwert et al., 2022; Hu et al., 2023).

Figure 1                6PPD reacts with ozone to form 6PPD-quinone (Image with permission from Zhenyu Tian, Barnett Institute, Northeastern University, USA)

The causal relationship between 6PPD-Q and urban runoff mortality syndrome in coho salmon was established by Tian et al. (2021), and subsequent work using a commercial analytical standard revised the juvenile coho LC50 to 95 ng/L (Tian et al., 2022). Early-life-stage juvenile coho have shown an even lower 24-h LC50 of 41 ng/L (Lo et al., 2023). Sensitivity is not uniform across salmonids: reported LC50 values are approximately 590 ng/L for brook trout and 1,000 ng/L for rainbow trout, while no mortality was observed in Arctic char or white sturgeon at substantially higher tested concentrations (Brinkmann et al., 2022). Tested freshwater invertebrates were also markedly less sensitive than coho salmon (Prosser et al., 2023). Field monitoring confirms that exposure is episodic and strongly associated with stormwater, with concentrations ranging from low ng/L to µg/L in urban-affected waters (Johannessen et al., 2022; Lane et al., 2024).

Regulatory frameworks are evolving in response to this evidence. In the United States, the US EPA has developed an acute freshwater screening value, a draft analytical method, and an information-gathering process under TSCA; California has separately listed motor vehicle tyres containing 6PPD as a Priority Product requiring alternatives analysis. In the United Kingdom, the Environment Agency has prioritised tyre additives, including 6PPD-Q, for further assessment. In the European Union, the Netherlands and Austria have notified an intention to prepare a REACH Annex XV restriction proposal for 6PPD and related PPD/PD substances used in rubber tyres (US EPA, 2024a; US EPA, 2024b; US EPA, 2024c; DTSC, 2023; Environment Agency, 2025; ECHA, 2026). This review integrates current evidence on occurrence, fate, toxicology, analytical measurement, regulatory status, and mitigation options relevant to researchers, regulators, and industry stakeholders.

  1. Chemical Properties, Environmental Fate, and Toxicology

6PPD-Q is an oxidised quinone transformation product of 6PPD. Experimentally measured aqueous solubility is 38 ± 10 µg/L and log KOW is 4.30 ± 0.02. Despite its hydrophobicity, 6PPD-Q can leach readily from tyre wear particles: flow-through simulations measured release of approximately 5.2 µg per gram of TWP over 6 h (Hu et al., 2023). Laboratory ozonation experiments further demonstrate that 6PPD forms 6PPD-Q alongside numerous other oxidative transformation products (Seiwert et al., 2022). Field studies have detected 6PPD-Q in stormwater-affected surface waters from low ng/L concentrations to µg/L peaks, with concentrations increasing markedly during rainfall events (Johannessen et al., 2022; Lane et al., 2024). Repeated road deposition and storm-driven mobilisation therefore create recurrent exposure pulses, while longer-term environmental persistence remains dependent on matrix and environmental conditions.

Acute toxicity is strongly species-dependent. Coho salmon are among the most sensitive species identified to date, with reported LC50 values of 95 ng/L for juvenile coho and 41 ng/L for early-life-stage juveniles (Tian et al., 2022; Lo et al., 2023). Brook trout and rainbow trout are less sensitive, with reported LC50 values of 590 ng/L and 1.00 µg/L, respectively, while Arctic char and white sturgeon showed no mortality at the highest concentrations tested in the same study (Brinkmann et al., 2022). Exposed sensitive fish show characteristic signs including increased ventilation, gasping, spiralling, erratic swimming, and loss of equilibrium before death (Brinkmann et al., 2022; Lo et al., 2023). In contrast, four freshwater invertebrate species showed no significant mortality at the highest tested concentrations, with no-effect concentrations in the µg/L range (Prosser et al., 2023). These findings caution against treating 6PPD-Q toxicity as uniform across salmonids or aquatic taxa.

Human exposure has now been demonstrated analytically, although its sources and health significance remain uncertain. A biomonitoring study in South China detected 6PPD and 6PPD-Q in human urine, and a subsequent study detected both compounds in paired plasma and urine samples (Du et al., 2022; Liu et al., 2024). These studies establish internal exposure but do not demonstrate that environmental concentrations cause adverse effects in humans. Potential exposure pathways include inhalation of tyre-associated particles and ingestion or dermal contact with contaminated environmental media, but the relative contribution of each pathway is not yet well resolved. Chronic human toxicological and epidemiological evidence is currently insufficient for robust quantitative human-health risk characterisation (Chen et al., 2023; Liu et al., 2024).

Overall, the evidence is strongest for acute ecological risk to coho salmon and some other sensitive fish during stormwater pulses. The wide interspecies variation in toxicity, recurrent urban runoff exposure, and continuing uncertainties in environmental fate justify targeted monitoring and further risk assessment (Tian et al., 2022; Brinkmann et al., 2022; Lo et al., 2023; Lane et al., 2024). Human exposure is measurable, but current evidence does not support direct extrapolation from aquatic toxicity to human-health effects (Du et al., 2022; Liu et al., 2024).

  1. Regulatory Status: United States, United Kingdom, and European Union

6PPD-Q has gained regulatory attention because of its acute aquatic toxicity, stormwater-driven occurrence, and demonstrated role in coho salmon mortality. The regulatory position described below is current to September 2026.

United States: The US EPA published an acute aquatic life screening value of 11 ng/L for 6PPD-Q in freshwater in May 2024. EPA explicitly describes this as a screening value rather than a recommended water quality criterion because the available toxicity dataset is insufficient for full criteria derivation (US EPA, 2024a). EPA also issued an Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking under TSCA Section 6 in 2024 to gather information on potential risks from 6PPD and 6PPD-Q and to inform possible subsequent regulatory action (US EPA, 2024b). Separately, California’s Department of Toxic Substances Control made motor vehicle tyres containing 6PPD a Safer Consumer Products Priority Product effective 1 October 2023, requiring manufacturers to undertake alternatives analysis (DTSC, 2023). EPA Draft Method 1634 provides an LC-MS/MS approach for aqueous 6PPD-Q monitoring but remains a draft, not-yet-approved method (US EPA, 2024c).

United Kingdom: The Environment Agency’s 2025 Chief Scientist’s Group assessment screened and prioritised tyre additives using available hazard, tonnage, and modelled exposure information. 6PPD-Q was among the substances identified for further detailed assessment, reflecting concern about its aquatic hazard and predicted environmental risk (Environment Agency, 2025). The report is a prioritisation exercise rather than a 6PPD-Q-specific statutory environmental quality standard or restriction, and it identifies additional data generation and refinement as necessary next steps.

European Union: The ECHA Registry of Restriction Intentions records a joint intention from the Netherlands and Austria to prepare a REACH restriction proposal covering certain phenyl-p-phenylenediamines and related para-substituted phenylenediamines, including 6PPD in rubber tyres and potentially other rubber goods. The intention was updated in May 2026 and lists 12 March 2027 as the expected Annex XV dossier submission date (ECHA, 2026). This is therefore a notified restriction intention, not yet a submitted or adopted EU restriction, and the eventual scope and risk-management measures remain subject to the REACH process.

Across the three jurisdictions, the common direction is toward improved exposure measurement, toxicity assessment, evaluation of alternatives, and reduction of high-risk releases, but the legal and technical stages differ. The United States currently combines a federal screening value and TSCA information gathering with California’s alternatives-analysis requirements; the United Kingdom is at a hazard/risk prioritisation and further-assessment stage; and the European Union has a notified REACH restriction intention with an Annex XV dossier expected in 2027 (US EPA, 2024a; US EPA, 2024b; DTSC, 2023; Environment Agency, 2025; ECHA, 2026).

  1. Analytical Methods, Human Health Risk, Regulatory Outlook, and Mitigation Strategies

Accurate measurement of 6PPD and 6PPD-Q is essential for environmental risk assessment because exposure is often episodic and closely linked to rainfall and roadway runoff. Event-triggered grab samples and event composites can both be useful, depending on whether the objective is to characterise peak concentration or integrated storm exposure (Johannessen et al., 2022; Lane et al., 2024). Sample handling is important because 6PPD-Q can sorb to laboratory materials; glass containers minimise losses compared with several alternative materials, and controlled cold storage can preserve samples for subsequent analysis (Hu et al., 2023; Lane et al., 2024). Sampling programmes should therefore be designed around storm timing as well as analytical sensitivity.

Analytical determination of 6PPD-Q is predominantly performed by liquid chromatography coupled to tandem or high-resolution mass spectrometry. Isotope-dilution LC-MS/MS enables low-ng/L quantification and helps correct for matrix effects and analytical losses (Tian et al., 2022). Extraction and clean-up requirements depend on the matrix: aqueous methods may use direct analysis or concentration steps, while solids and tyre-derived materials require matrix-appropriate solvent extraction and clean-up (Chen et al., 2023). QA/QC should include method blanks, calibration verification, isotope-labelled standards, recovery or matrix-performance checks, and appropriate duplicates or replicates. US EPA Draft Method 1634 provides a formal isotope-dilution LC-MS/MS framework for aqueous matrices; however, it remains a draft method and should not be described as a fully approved harmonised standard (US EPA, 2024c).

Human biomonitoring has moved the discussion from hypothetical exposure to demonstrated internal exposure. 6PPD and 6PPD-Q have been measured in urine, and both compounds have also been reported in paired plasma and urine samples (Du et al., 2022; Liu et al., 2024). These findings are important for exposure assessment, but they do not by themselves establish toxicity, disease causation, or a quantitative human-health risk. Potential inhalation, ingestion, and dermal pathways require further source-apportionment work, and chronic human-specific toxicological and epidemiological datasets remain limited (Chen et al., 2023). Consequently, human-health conclusions should remain cautious and should be separated from the much stronger evidence for acute aquatic toxicity.

Regulatory attention is likely to remain focused on filling these evidence gaps while evaluating practical risk-management options. In the United States, the 2024 TSCA ANPRM is an information-gathering step that may inform later regulatory action, and California manufacturers are progressing alternatives analyses (US EPA, 2024b; DTSC, 2023). In the United Kingdom, the Environment Agency’s 2025 prioritisation identifies the need for further assessment of tyre additives including 6PPD-Q (Environment Agency, 2025). In the European Union, the Netherlands and Austria have notified a REACH restriction intention, with the Annex XV dossier expected in March 2027 (ECHA, 2026).

Mitigation should address both source and pathway. Source-side measures include evaluating alternative antiozonants, reformulation, or other approaches that reduce formation or release of 6PPD-Q; however, candidate alternatives require rigorous assessment of tyre performance, road safety, environmental hazard, and the potential for regrettable substitution (DTSC, 2023; ECHA, 2026). Pathway controls can reduce the quantity of roadway-derived contamination reaching surface waters. In a full-scale field study, a mature bioretention cell reduced 6PPD-Q mass loading by approximately an order of magnitude, and modelling indicated greater than approximately 90% reduction under most typical storm conditions (Rodgers et al., 2023). Because 6PPD-Q can leach from TWPs and occur in the dissolved phase, mitigation systems should be evaluated for removal of both particle-associated and dissolved contaminant fractions (Hu et al., 2023).

  1. Conclusions

6PPD-Q is an emerging contaminant of substantial ecological concern because stormwater concentrations can overlap with acute-effect concentrations for coho salmon. The strongest evidence supports exceptional sensitivity of coho salmon, while toxicity varies by orders of magnitude among other fish and invertebrate species (Tian et al., 2022; Brinkmann et al., 2022; Lo et al., 2023; Prosser et al., 2023). Storm-driven monitoring is therefore critical for identifying biologically relevant exposure pulses (Johannessen et al., 2022; Lane et al., 2024).

The regulatory picture is advancing but should be described precisely. The United States has an acute freshwater screening value, a TSCA information-gathering process, and California alternatives-analysis requirements; the United Kingdom has prioritised 6PPD-Q for further assessment; and the European Union has a notified REACH restriction intention from the Netherlands and Austria, with an Annex XV dossier expected in 2027 (US EPA, 2024a; US EPA, 2024b; DTSC, 2023; Environment Agency, 2025; ECHA, 2026). Human exposure has been demonstrated through biomonitoring, but the evidence base is not yet sufficient to quantify chronic human-health risk (Du et al., 2022; Liu et al., 2024).

Risk reduction should combine robust, storm-event-focused measurement with source-side alternatives assessment and proven runoff controls. Bioretention currently provides direct field evidence for substantial reduction of 6PPD-Q mass loading, while development of safer tyre formulations should proceed with careful assessment of functional performance and replacement-chemical hazards (Rodgers et al., 2023; DTSC, 2023). Continued analytical standardisation, environmental monitoring, and species-specific toxicological research will be essential for proportionate and scientifically defensible management of 6PPD-Q.

References

Brinkmann, M., Montgomery, D., Selinger, S., Miller, J.G.P., Stock, E., Alcaraz, A.J., Challis, J.K., Weber, L., Janz, D., Hecker, M. and Wiseman, S., 2022. Acute toxicity of the tire rubber-derived chemical 6PPD-Quinone to four fishes of commercial, cultural, and ecological importance. Environmental Science & Technology Letters, 9(4), pp.333–338. doi:10.1021/acs.estlett.2c00050.

Chen, X., He, T., Yang, X., Gan, Y., Qing, X., Wang, J. and Huang, Y., 2023. Analysis, environmental occurrence, fate and potential toxicity of tire wear compounds 6PPD and 6PPD-Quinone. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 452, 131245. doi:10.1016/j.jhazmat.2023.131245.

Department of Toxic Substances Control (DTSC), 2023. Adopted Priority Product: Motor Vehicle Tires Containing 6PPD. California Safer Consumer Products Program. Available at: https://dtsc.ca.gov/scp/motor_vehicle_tires_containing_6ppd/ (Accessed: 25 September 2026).

Du, B., Liang, B., Li, Y., Shen, M., Liu, L.-Y. and Zeng, L., 2022. First report on the occurrence of N-(1,3-dimethylbutyl)-N′-phenyl-p-phenylenediamine (6PPD) and 6PPD-Quinone as pervasive pollutants in human urine from South China. Environmental Science & Technology Letters, 9(12), pp.1056–1062. doi:10.1021/acs.estlett.2c00821.

Environment Agency, 2025. Hazard screening and UK risk prioritisation for tyre additives. Chief Scientists Group, Environment Agency, UK. Published 18 July 2025.

European Chemicals Agency (ECHA), 2026. Registry of Restriction Intentions until Outcome: Certain phenyl-p-phenylenediamines (PPDs) and other para-substituted phenylenediamines (PDs). Available at: https://echa.europa.eu/registry-of-restriction-intentions (Accessed: 25 September 2026).

Hu, X., Zhao, H.N., Tian, Z., Peter, K.T., Dodd, M.C. and Kolodziej, E.P., 2023. Chemical characteristics, leaching, and stability of the ubiquitous tire rubber-derived toxicant 6PPD-Quinone. Environmental Science: Processes & Impacts, 25(5), pp.901–911. doi:10.1039/D3EM00047H.

Johannessen, C., Helm, P., Lashuk, B., Yargeau, V. and Metcalfe, C.D., 2022. The tire wear compounds 6PPD-Quinone and 1,3-diphenylguanidine in an urban watershed. Archives of Environmental Contamination and Toxicology, 82(2), pp.171–179. doi:10.1007/s00244-021-00878-4.

Lane, R.F., Smalling, K.L., Bradley, P.M., Greer, J.B., Gordon, S.E., Hansen, J.D., Kolpin, D.W., Spanjer, A.R. and Masoner, J.R., 2024. Tire-derived contaminants 6PPD and 6PPD-Q: analysis, sample handling, and reconnaissance of United States stream exposures. Chemosphere, 363, 142830. doi:10.1016/j.chemosphere.2024.142830.

Liu, C., Zhao, X., Guo, L., Yu, Q., Zhang, W., Peng, Z. et al., 2024. Emerging N-(1,3-dimethylbutyl)-N′-phenyl-p-phenylenediamine (6PPD) and 6PPD quinone in paired human plasma and urine from Tianjin, China: preliminary assessment with demographic factors. Journal of Hazardous Materials, 476, 134818. doi:10.1016/j.jhazmat.2024.134818.

Lo, B.P., Marlatt, V.L., Liao, X., Reger, S., Gallilee, C., Ross, A.R.S. and Brown, T.M., 2023. Acute toxicity of 6PPD-Quinone to early life stage juvenile Chinook (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) and coho (Oncorhynchus kisutch) salmon. Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry, 42(4), pp.815–822. doi:10.1002/etc.5568.

Prosser, R.S., Salole, J. and Hang, S., 2023. Toxicity of 6PPD-Quinone to four freshwater invertebrate species. Environmental Pollution, 337, 122512. doi:10.1016/j.envpol.2023.122512.

Rodgers, T.F.M., Wang, Y., Humes, C., Jeronimo, M., Johannessen, C., Spraakman, S., Giang, A. and Scholes, R.C., 2023. Bioretention cells provide a 10-fold reduction in 6PPD-Quinone mass loadings to receiving waters: evidence from a field experiment and modeling. Environmental Science & Technology Letters, 10(7), pp.582–588. doi:10.1021/acs.estlett.3c00203.

Seiwert, B., Nihemaiti, M., Troussier, M., Weyrauch, S. and Reemtsma, T., 2022. Abiotic oxidative transformation of 6-PPD and 6-PPD quinone from tires and occurrence of their products in snow from urban roads and in municipal wastewater. Water Research, 212, 118122. doi:10.1016/j.watres.2022.118122.

Tian, Z., Zhao, H., Peter, K.T., Gonzalez, M., Wetzel, J., Wu, C. et al., 2021. A ubiquitous tire rubber-derived chemical induces acute mortality in coho salmon. Science, 371(6525), pp.185–189. doi:10.1126/science.abd6951.

Tian, Z., Gonzalez, M., Rideout, C.A., Zhao, H.N., Hu, X., Wetzel, J., Mudrock, E., James, C.A., McIntyre, J.K. and Kolodziej, E.P., 2022. 6PPD-Quinone: revised toxicity assessment and quantification with a commercial standard. Environmental Science & Technology Letters, 9(2), pp.140–146. doi:10.1021/acs.estlett.1c00910.

US Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), 2024a. Acute Aquatic Life Screening Value for 6PPD-Quinone in Freshwater. EPA 822-R-24-004. Office of Water, Washington, DC.

US Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), 2024b. Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking on 6PPD and Its Transformation Product, 6PPD-Quinone. Toxic Substances Control Act Section 6. Available at: https://www.epa.gov/assessing-and-managing-chemicals-under-tsca/advance-notice-proposed-rulemaking-6ppd-and-its (Accessed: 25 September 2026).

US Environmental Protection Agency (US EPA), 2024c. Draft Method 1634: Determination of 6PPD-Quinone in Aqueous Matrices Using Liquid Chromatography with Tandem Mass Spectrometry (LC/MS/MS). EPA 821-D-24-001. Office of Water, Washington, DC.

Ken Scally1,2

1Calibre Scientific, Ireland, 2Mount Royal University, Calgary, Canada

Article Loss Prevention

Collateral Warranties and Third Party Reliance on Reports

- by
Tags: Featured

The AGS Loss Prevention Working Group undertook a survey of members in 2024 requesting comments on their recent and current commercial, contractual and legal issues which have affected their organisations in the previous 12 months.  17 comments were received which covered a variety of topics.  One of the most significant areas of concern for responding members related to third party reliance on reports and collateral warranties.

The main concerns were regarding the requests for rights to unlimited reliance letters or collateral warranties, the ability to charge for reliance letters and collateral warranties, and the lack of understanding clients have about what they are asking for and why it might not be acceptable.

Over the years the AGS has published a number of documents which are relevant to this issue, namely

Loss Prevention Guidance 011 – The Contract (Rights of Third Parties) Act (updated 2022),

Loss Prevention Guidance 024 – Collateral warranties (updated 2022),

Loss Prevention Alert 11 – Confusion about Assignments (2000) (updated 2026),

Loss Prevention Alert 45 – Assignment of Reports (2011) (updated 2026),

Loss Prevention Alert 68 – Duty of Care arising from Third Party Reliance on a geotechnical report (2018), and

Loss Prevention Alert 76 – Reliance on another company’s Report (2023).

The information in these documents can help AGS members navigate their way through the issues around collateral warranties and third party reliance, and to help them inform their clients about these issues.  This article summarises the main points in relation to AGS members’ concerns, but it is strongly recommended that members review the guidance mentioned above produced by the AGS LPWG.

How third parties can be given rights in a contract

  1. Under the Contract (Rights of Third Parties) Act 1999 any third party may enforce a contractual term in a contract if that contract expressly gives them the right to do so, or if the contractual term purports to confer a benefit on the third party. Further information on the Act is given in LPG 011.
  2. Another way rights (for example the benefit of a report, ie the right to rely on it) can be assigned to a third party is by formal assignment. Depending on the terms of the report author’s appointment, this assignment may, or may not, be subject to notification to the report author. See LPA 11 and LPA 45.
  3. A third way is by way of a letter of reliance. Reliance letters typically relate to named report(s) that the third party can rely on. See LPA 68 and LPA 76.
  4. A fourth way is by using collateral warranties, or duty of care agreements, which are contracts ancillary to an appointment or building contract. Collateral warranties relate to all the professional services and advice provided under the appointment, not only the formal reports issued as part of the services. LPG 024 explains collateral warranties.

Formal assignments, reliance letters and collateral warranties create direct contractual links between third parties (such as future occupiers of buildings and funders of projects) and the consultants or contractors with whom such third parties would ordinarily have no contractual link.

Considerations associated with giving third party rights

One should avoid providing third party rights without carefully considering the business risks and the commercial implications. There is a multiplication of these risks to the warrantor if numerous warranties (or ‘letters of reliance’) are given. There is also a considerable burden of administration in providing and keeping track of the warranties, and dealing with insurance.  The period of risk could be extended by the warranty.  The beneficiary of the warranty or reliance letter, or assignee under an assignment contract, may not be a party to the primary works contract, and indeed may have requirements and business attitudes different to the original client.  Attention should be paid to the proposed development and any changes that may have occurred to plans since your work.

The level of professional indemnity cover should be considered.  Losses suffered by the third party may be of a type and extent that the original client may not have suffered and may include substantial consequential losses, such as business interruption losses and so forth.  The rights acquired by the third party are valuable and include the right to sue if the report contains errors which cause them to suffer loss.  With multiple collateral warranties or third party reliance letters there could be multiple actions, cumulatively exceeding the level of professional indemnity insurance cover, and hence exposing the insured’s own financial resources.

As well as the level of PI cover, insurance policy wording may include specific conditions relating to third party reliance.  Members should ensure they carefully review any obligations to provide these prior to signing a contract, with careful consideration of how those obligations might interact with their insurance policy exclusions.

The AGS member should consider giving the third party a copy of the AGS Client Guide to Professional Indemnity Insurance which aims to assist clients to better understand PI insurance issues and the need for agreement with their advisors and designers on the most sensible allocation of financial risk.

The contract of assignment, reliance letter or collateral warranty must have more than a nominal value to those requesting them, as otherwise why would it be required?  AGS members should consider all aspects relating to the increase in risk associated with entering in to an assignment or warranty or issuing a letter of reliance, and look to making a realistic charge for doing so, particularly if requested after the primary contract has been signed.  LPA 45 gives some guidance on matters to consider when determining what to charge.

Article provided by David Hutchinson (AGS Honorary member)

Article Loss Prevention

Gender Specific Welfare & PPE – Does it matter?

- by
Tags: Featured

Welfare and PPE provision on engineering sites has been recognised as historically poor in general and often, specifically for women, non-existent.  In recent times this has certainly improved but is enough being done? Indeed, what is ‘enough’?

Laws such as the Personal Protective Equipment at Work Regulations 1992 and its 2022 amendment place a duty on every employer in Great Britain to ensure that suitable PPE is provided to employees who may be exposed to a risk to their health or safety while at work.  (See AGS Safety Guidance – Personal Protective Equipment (PPE) for more information on the types and use of PPE relating to the activities of AGS members.)

In addition, employers should be aware that they may be subject to contractual requirements relating to welfare of employees and site visitors. There may also be non-specific requirements relating to welfare of female workers, which fall under contractual obligations to demonstrate compliance with published company statements or policies. These policies may be documents published by the client and deemed to have been read and accepted, or policies submitted by contractors as part of pre-qualification or tender processes. Examples of these are Equality, Diversity and Inclusivity (EDI) type policies. It is important that the implications and requirements of such policies are identified and implemented, as non-compliance could be viewed as being in breach of contract and possibly leave contractors open to claims.

Traditional ‘one size fits all’ approaches are no longer likely to meet the legal and contractual requirements of projects. It is no longer acceptable to provide women with PPE designed for men. PPE designed to accommodate the specific shape of women is now readily available, which is much safer and comfortable for long term wear.  The provision of correctly sized PPE also promotes equality, inclusivity, and demonstrates respect and appreciation of female workers.

Provision of separate gender specific hygiene facilities, especially where the workforce is diverse and has a mix of ethnicities and cultures, is essential if equality and inclusivity objectives are to be met. In some cases, EDI policies require provision of female hygiene products, which can remove significant anxieties and lost work time for some women working on site. The details of such provisions need to be considered based on specific workforce needs, but it is recognised that a valued and supported workforce is also likely to be more content and productive as a result.

It is clear that welfare ‘equality and inclusivity’ done properly no longer simply consists of provision of a ladies’ toilet, and that there can be significant contractual and ethical drivers, as well as appreciable benefits to be had from a more robust consideration of gender specific welfare.

Article provided by Jo Strange (AGS Honorary member)

Article News Business Practice Contaminated Land Data Management Executive Geotechnical Instrumentation & Monitoring Laboratories Loss Prevention Safety Sustainability

AGS Awards 2026: Celebrating Outstanding Contributions in Geoscience

- by

Congratulations to the winners of the AGS Awards 2026, which recognise the exceptional dedication, expertise and commitment shown by members across our nine Working Groups.

Each year, our Working Group Leaders nominate individuals who have made significant contributions to the AGS and to the wider geotechnical and geoenvironmental community.

This year’s winners represent a broad range of specialisms across the industry, highlighting the valuable work undertaken by AGS members to advance best practice, share knowledge and support the continued development of the profession.

The following individuals were recognised for their outstanding contributions:

Business Practice Working Group Award

  • Award: David Hutchinson, AGS Honorary Member

Contaminated Land Working Group Award

  • Award: Mike Plimmer, Geotechnical & Environmental Associates
  • Commendation: Chris Evans, Socotec

Data Management Working Group Award

  • Award: Conrad Stewart, Harrison Group Environmental
  • Commendation: Mark Bevan, Structural Soils

Geotechnical Working Group Award

  • Award: Jai Shah, Ramboll
  • Commendation: Georgina Donbroski, RSK

Laboratories Working Group Award

  • Award: John Masters, Geolabs

Loss Prevention Working Group Award

  • Award: Kathryn Eva, Beale & Co
  • Commendation: Peter Plumpton, Socotec

Safety Working Group Award

  • Award: Madeleine Bardsley, WSP
  • Commendation: Will Capps, Lucion Group

Sustainability Working Group Award

  • Award: Natalie Cropp, Tony Gee and Partners
  • Commendation: Sarah Cook, Onyx Geo Consulting

 

Lifetime Achievement Awards

  • Jackie Bland, Structural Soils
  • Jonathan Gammon, Honorary Member

The AGS would like to congratulate all award recipients and commend them for their ongoing commitment and contributions to the Association. Their work continues to support the advancement of standards, collaboration and knowledge-sharing across the geotechnical and geoenvironmental sector.

Article Business Practice Contaminated Land Data Management Development Fund Executive Geotechnical Instrumentation & Monitoring Laboratories Loss Prevention Safety Sustainability

Early Careers Poster Competition 2026 – The Results!

- by

Thank you to everyone who entered this year’s AGS Early Careers Poster Competition, which followed the themed Top Five Industry Insights. We received 16 high-quality, full-colour submissions, each offering a unique and thoughtful interpretation of the brief.

Our judging panel, Vivien Dent (AGS Past Chair, Environment Agency), Jonathan Gammon (AGS Past Chair), Geraint Williams (AGS Chair Elect and HKA) and Bradley Falcus (Central Alliance), had the challenging task of selecting a winner from a strong field of entries. After careful consideration, they were delighted to announce Yasamin Bayley (Fairhurst) as the overall winner, who’s colour poster was created using collage.

Congratulations to Yasamin, who has been awarded a £100 Amazon voucher, complimentary entry to the sold-out AGS Annual Conference, and a double-page spread in AGS Magazine, showcasing her poster and the inspiration behind it.

We would also like to congratulate our ten runners-up: Pagen Spooner (EPG), Arun Woods (Sutcliffe), Daniel D Gbenro (United Utilities), James Tasker (Binnies UK), Jenny Farrant (Lithos Consulting), Joanna Wilks (Cowi UK), Kevin Perreau (BakerHicks), Sam Murray (Scottish Power Renewables), Visar Rugova (Cowi UK), and Zoe Guy (Crossfield Consulting). Each runner-up has received complimentary entry to the AGS Annual Conference in London on 19th March.

Thank you once again to all who took the time to participate. Every entry will be displayed at the AGS Annual Conference, where they will be viewed by over 240 delegates, a fitting showcase for the creativity and insight of our early career professionals.